Welcome back and we’re going to the kitchens now to learn how to make perfect bagels. And they’re really easy to do, aren’t they, Cliff?
Yes, that’s right. Even if you’ve never baked bread and you don’t have a set of kitchen scales, you can bake perfect bagels if you have about half an hour to spare.
Half an hour? That’s great. Can I do it?
You sure can, Cliff, and we’re going to do it right here on the show.
Well, all right. You guys ready to cook some bagels? Let’s do it.
Ingredients
1 1/8 cups warm water (just above room temperature)
1 tbs vegetable oil
2 tbs malt syrup, molasses, or sugar (you can substitute maple syrup or honey if you like, but you’ll taste it. But go for it if you like.)
1 tsp salt
3 1/3 cup bread (or strong) flour
2tsp active dry yeast
Make your dough
a) If you have a mixer with a dough hook
Mix the water, syrup (or sugar or whatever your sweet thing is) and the yeast and let the liquid mixture stand for five minutes, then and add half the flour and all the other dry ingredients. Turn on the mixer for about a minute, then add the remaining flour until you have a ball. If it’s too dry, add more water a tablespoon at a time. The dough hook will do the kneading in about five minutes. Give it a three minutes on slow and about two on half speed to knock it about. If you’re using fast-acting yeast, skip the first rise. I use fast acting stuff and it works out fine.
b)If you’re mixing by hand
Mix the water, syrup (or sugar or whatever your sweet thing is) and the yeast and let the liquid mixture stand for five minutes. Put two cups of the flour with the salt in a large bowl and stir in the liquid. I’d use two wooden spoons for this, as it cuts down on mess. Then add the rest of the flour and stir a bit more until you get a dough. Turn this out onto a floured board. Remember to flour the board and your hands, never the dough. Knead by hand for about 10 minutes until smooth and elastic. Skip the first rise if you are using fast-acting yeast.
First rise
Bear in mind that most yeast sold in the supermarket is fast-acting, so you can probably skip this part. But if it’s ordinary yeast, put the dough in a large bowl. Brush oil lightly over one side of cling film and place this over the bowl with the greased side down. Let it sit in a warm place for about an hour. It should double in size, but don’t worry if it hasn’t risen by as much as that.
Whether you’ve skipped the first rise or not, you’ve not got your basic dough. Easy.

Shape the bagels
Give it a quick knead again to knock the air out a bit. It’ll all come out anyway, because next you’re going to roll it out flat about 14 inches across. Don’t worry about getting it exactly right, it’s just to get the dough breathing. I use the length of a rolling pin as a guide, like so:
Do this on a well floured surface with a rolling pin. If you don’t have one, you can skip this step. Once it’s flat, let it rest for five minutes. Then squish it all back together and with a divide it into eight pieces.
With two hands, make a ball out of each one. Don’t roll them out, just cup them in your hands like you’re making a snowball. Then flatten them slightly and stick a finger through the middle, keep turning them so they get stretched evenly as you pull the middles bigger and until you have a decent sized hole that you can get three fingers in.
Put these on a non-stick, lightly greased baking tray.
Second rise
Lightly brush oil on one side of some cling film and lay it oily side down across the top of the bagels in the tray.
Don’t make it too greasy, the oil is just there just to stop the dough sticking to the cloth, not to add any flavour or texture to the bagels. Leave them aside in a warm place and let them rise for about 20 minutes.
Preheat your oven now to about 220C/400F, because you’re going to need it really hot. And make sure you put a cake tray or shallow casserole dish in the bottom of the oven while it’s heating - I’ll come back to this in a second.
Boiling
While your oven is getting nice and hot, start boiling a large pot with at least 4 inches of water in it, and when your 20 minutes are up, and the bagels have risen under the cling film, you’re going to drop them into the boiling water. You can do 3 or 4 at a time, just make sure they have room to float around a bit.
They’re going to expand quite a bit, so start with a couple to begin with. Put them top side down into the water first, because they will look better in the end. They may sink down to the bottom for a bit, but they will rise up, and you want to boil them for about a minute each side, turning them once, before taking them out with a slotted spoon or a spatula and putting them on a rack. You could put them on a tea towel if you don’t have a rack, but don’t use a plate, because they need to dry off so let the air get to them to dry out a bit.
Baking
Brush them with a little water, add some poppy seeds, or sesame seeds or anything you like. Onions, cinnamon, whatever. If you’re adding nothing at all, still brush them with water because it’ll given them a light glaze. Put the bagels, now nice and puffy and thick, back onto your baking tray. You can pack them close together now - they aren’t going to rise any more.
Remember that shallow tray in the hot oven? That’s the key to a really good glaze, because you’re improvising to make a steam oven. Get a small glass of cold water or a half dozen ice cubes and pour/put them into the dish in the bottom of your oven. This will steam bake your bagels, which is the best way to cook them. Whack the bagels in straight away in the middle shelf and bake for 20 minutes or until the tops are golden brown. You can take them out halfway through and brush them with water. It’ll help with the finish, but don’t leave the oven door open longer than a few seconds, because you have to keep the oven hot for bagels. Don’t brush them too much if you’ve added poppy seeds, because they’ll fall right off.
And that’s it.
Let them cool on a rack.
They freeze really well because bagels are more dense than bread, but you’ll want to eat at least one straight away.